Time for a tax ballot? Author: Steve Trinward
Posted on 02.10.11 by Steve Trinward

So now the truth comes out from the Leftist press: it’s not a matter of what’s right, just what’s customary!

The recent attempts by Republican Congressthings to let people exempt themselves from paying taxes for abortions SHOULD have prompted a movement to make ALL aspects of government “opt in”; instead, it has led only to “progressive” pundits from all over that realm of the political spectrum saying things like, “We pay taxes for a lot of things that we don’t agree with. Why should this be any different?”

In light of the legacy of war-tax resistance, along with so many other examples of civil disobedience in the leftist heritage, it’s amazing to see such weak-kneed justification for cracking down on anti-abortion sentiments as something evil and nefarious (and dare I say it, implicitly ‘un-American’?). After all, the convictions of those who consider abortion to be “murder” are no less valid than those who consider wars (or at least the vast majority of them) or the death-penalty to be such, and who object to funding those atrocities.

It’s also kinda strange to see “progressives” so openly advocating the statist-quo. One would think that these allegedly forward-looking (hence the name?) folks would see this as an opening to create voluntarism in government, starting with its weakest point: the funding! Instead of marching in the streets, we could indeed be ‘voting with our wallets” and refusing to pay for wars, corporate bailouts and other things considered anathema to progressive/liberal/whatever-ya-call-it-these-days intentions.

Consider the possibilities if they were willing to grant liberty (aka “choice”) to those they claim oppose it: today we allow some people to deflect their taxes from paying for abortions; tomorrow we allow others to refuse to pay for corporate bailouts; the next day we stop participating in the funding of war, unless we specifically choose to do so.

It’s called a “tax ballot” and it is clearly time to raise it as a discussable issue once more. The concept is simple: allow taxpayers the option of filling out one more form when they file that 1040, a form listing a general overview of government programs now in existence, with a column of blanks beside it. Those who choose to avail themselves of this could then fill those blanks with percentages (or dollar amounts, based on the actual bottom line on that 1040), indicating what they wish to support out of that government smorgasbord, and to what extent. (By leaving a row blank, they could indicate that under no circumstances should one penny of their tax payment go to back THAT program or aspect of the Federal game.)

As a valid precedent, I can only point to one of the grandest examples of using “choice” to promote a similarly controversial issue. In fact, it involved the very same issue: abortion funding. It happened back in the early 1970s, some 40 years ago, at the University of Maine’s main campus in Orono. The Student Council faced a confrontation over whether or not student activities fees could be applied to “health services” broadly enough to encompass a loan fund for students seeking to obtain abortions.

One side of the debate proclaimed that denying this assistance (in the form of loans, not subsidies or gifts) was discriminating against those students whose medical needs were just as valid as anyone else’s among the student body. The other side said this policy was forcing them to support something they considered to be “murder.” They were both right, and the Student Council had to find a solution to please both sides.

The Council president at the time was a young man named Bill Eames. (He had also been a childhood friend and neighbor of mine back in our hometown of Bethel, but that’s not really important here.) According to accounts presented since then, it was he who came up with the ultimate answer: anyone who wished to support the abortion loan fund was to signify so in writing. Only by “opting in” to the loan fund as a target for a portion of one’s individual activity fee would those funds be in any way connected to the funding of student abortions. Those who wanted to keep their payment money out of the pool had no action required of them.

The measure passed; the fund was established; and things settled down until the next campus-wide controversy. Over the next several years there were a number of young women who, when faced with that difficult choice, had at least one more option open to them.

It would sure be nice if we could offer all taxpayers such a wider set of options, on any and all of the issues that matter to them. A good place to start might be this proposed abortion opt-out, although it would be far more valid if it were an “opt in” for those who choose to support the program… or any other aspect of the Federal government.

But then the Federal gummint of the U.S. would be showing as much good sense as a rural Maine country boy once did… and that’s probably too much to ask!

Filed under: Feature Articles | Report Bad Link

Bookmark this post in Furl or

Iraq Deaths Estimator

US Deaths in Afghanistan: Obama vs Bush. Click here to learn more.

Subscribe to Rational Review News Digest


Archives by Date
June 2012
April 2011
February 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
February 2005
March 2004
February 2004

Archives by Category

Credits and Copyright
Proudly powered by WordPress. All articles © 2004-2005 the authors.
Custom WordPress theme by Brad Spangler.


Rational Review News Digest is supported by reader contributions. Please help us to continue bringing you your daily headlines:

For a one-time contribution:

We accept credit cards and direct donations via PayPal(tm).

Click here to become one of our subscribing contributors!

If you'd prefer to mail a check, cash or money order, please contact Thomas L. Knapp for postal address information.

Contributions to Rational Review are NOT tax-deductible.


A Drug War Carol
A Subterranean Perspective
ALLiance Journal a journal of theory and strategy from the Alliance of the Libertarian Left
Atlas Magazine
Bill of Rights — Security Edition
Bill of Rights Enforcement
Brad Spangler
Civilian Self Defense Blog
Doing Freedom
FireArm News
Forfeiture Endangers American Rights
Free Market News Network
Free Patriot Press
Free State Project
Freedom’s Phoenix
Fresno County LP
from Reason to Freedom
Gun Law News
Gun News
Gun Owners of America
Gun Watch Monitoring people’s right to effective self-defence
Healing Our World An online version of Dr. Mary Ruwart’s excellent book (since updated), outlining how
Humboldt County LP
International Society for Individual Liberty
ISWFACE International Sex Worker Foundation for Art, Culture and Education
I[ndividual]Feminist Where feminism and libertarianism meet and merge into a true concern for individual liberty
Kn@ppster blogsite Tom Knapp’s regular ramblings on revolution, radicalism and liberty
Libertarian Strategy Monthly
Liberty Activist
Liberty Book Shop
Liberty For All
Literary Rags
No Force, No Fraud
North American Samizdat
North American Samizdat
Psycho Guantanamo Blog
Reboot the Republic
Smiling Albino
Solano County LP
Sovereigns of the High Frontier
Strike the Root
The Agitator
The Choice Channel
The Exterritorial Imperative
The Lawyer
The Libertarian
The Libertarian Enterprise
Tibor R. Machan
Tinfoil Beanie
Today in Political History
Traffic Exchange Mastery: The Blog
Unknown News
Unknown News
War on Guns